2014–2015
|
| Kathryn Bartel |
St. Mary’s Springs Academy |
| John Franco |
Waukegan High School |
| Lori Keough |
St. Charles High School |
| Vince Kube |
Columbus High School |
| David Moon |
Reedsburg High School |
| Pam Smith |
Florence High School |
2015–2016
|
| Val Crofts |
Milton High School |
| Anna-Lisa Dahlgren |
Marshall High School |
| Kevin Gleeson |
Thomas More High School |
| Rick Kelm |
Ripon High School |
| Berry Mellen |
Sturgeon Bay High School |
| Ryan Mussack |
Sauk Prairie High School |
| Sarah Pica |
Cameron High School |
| Steven Stary |
Notre Dame High School |
2016–2017
|
| Evan Abt |
Heritage Christian High School |
| Benjamin Hubing |
Greendale High School |
| Steven LeBre |
Heritage Christian High School |
| Bob Spice |
DePere High School |
| Peter Sehloff |
Fox Valley Lutheran High School |
2017–2018
|
| Nick Adams |
Madison East High School |
| Patrick Coffey |
Brookfield East High School |
| Patrick Idstein |
St. Thomas More High School |
| Dan Kelly |
West Des Moines High School |
| Tim McLean |
St. Francis High School |